Guest Reviews of Shelburne Murray Hill Hotel New York Based on a 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) rating system

4.3 Overall
4.6 Rooms
3.3 Location
3.9 Service
2.9 Facilities
What people say about: Overall (show overall reviews)
Showing: all reviews positive negative
  1.  
    A lovely hotel

    Expedia, 24 Jun 2009

  2.  
    Great location and comfortable rooms.

    Expedia, 24 Jun 2009

  3.  
    The staff were very friendly and the rooms were quite roomy and clean.

    TripAdvisor, 23 Jun 2009

  4.  
    Great Stay at Affinia!

    TripAdvisor, 23 Jun 2009

  5.  
    However, this time as I was traveling with two teenagers -- the idea of two bathrooms was quite enticing -- not to mention the great Travelzoo rate ($199 for a 1 bedroom suite).

    TripAdvisor, 23 Jun 2009

  1.  
    All in all, the hotel and location were great and we will definitely stay here again -- in fact, I am planning an "all girls" (with sisters and nieces) trip for next summer and will definitely look into staying here again.

    TripAdvisor, 23 Jun 2009

  2.  
    On the plus side, the hotel has become downright stylish, with modern, attractive decor, improved lighting, welcoming public areas, and a vibe that is much hipper and far less like staying at your grandmother's.

    TripAdvisor, 22 Jun 2009

  3.  
    All in all, it's still a good hotel in a great location, but the renovation is not necessarily an improvement.

    TripAdvisor, 22 Jun 2009

  4.  
    I have also stayed in the San Carlos which is far superior and the Courtyard Marriott (several times) where the customer service is absolutely excellent.

    TripAdvisor, 21 Jun 2009

  5.  
    Firstly, we got an excellent price (40% discount) through Hotels.com.

    TripAdvisor, 21 Jun 2009

Loading...