Guest Reviews of Shelburne Murray Hill Hotel New York Based on a 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) rating system

4.3 Overall
4.6 Rooms
3.3 Location
3.9 Service
2.9 Facilities
What people say about: Value (show overall reviews)
Showing: all reviews positive negative
  1.  
    A bit pricey but still worth it.

    TripAdvisor, 04 Jun 2009

  2.  
    They have been renovating the entire hotel for months but I felt the minor inconveniences (fitness center not open but can use sister property a few blocks away, etc) were worth the price and location.

    hotels.com, 19 May 2009

  3.  
    Excellent value.

    Expedia, 13 May 2009

  4.  
    Overall, my husband and I were very pleased, thought the value was great for NYC, and we will return!

    Priceline, 25 Feb 2009

  5.  
    This hotel is FANTASTIC VALUE.

    IgoUgo, 11 Jun 2008

  1.  
    GREAT Value

    Travelocity, 01 Apr 2008

  2.  
    Very good value for a great hotel.

    Yahoo! Travel, 07 Jun 2007

  3.  
    The hotel was a pretty decent value in terms of room size, but the lobby and other common areas far exceed the cleanliness and stylishness of the rooms.

    TravelPost.com, 22 Nov 2005

  4.  
    We found it great value for money.

    TripAdvisor, 25 May 2009

  5.  
    Beds comfortable Very quiet rooms Staff was friendly Close to alot of eateries Great Value Cons 5 long block walk to subway Subway transfer generally needed Staff not very helpful in knowing the sights Tips Great Italian-La Masseria Great Dining Experience-McCormick & Schick Crab Feed for $20 on Sunday Nights Buy the weeklong $25.00

    TripAdvisor, 21 Apr 2009

Loading...